incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Justin Mclean <>
Subject Re: [VOTE] Apache Sirona 0.2-incubating
Date Wed, 25 Jun 2014 07:25:18 GMT

Sorry I been a bit busy with travel and other releases over the last few weeks.

-1 binding due to vote issues, NOTICE and binaries in source release.

I checked:
- missing VOTE RESULT and can't tell if there are 3 +1 binding votes or not. There are 4 +1
votes on of which one is not  binding but unsure re the others. Only one of the +1 votes is
listed as a PMC member here [1] and the project is not listed here [2].
- artefact name includes incubating 
- signatures and md5 hash all good
- DISCLAIMER present
- LICENSE correct
- NOTICE file includes too many things (see below)
- binary files in source release (see bleow)
- can compile from source
- test failed (JavaAgent) - up to you if you think this is an issue or not

In the NOTICE file you have:
 SB Admin Theme (Apache)
 Twitter bootstrap (MIT) 
 Bootstrap datetimepicker (Apache)
 Table sorter (MIT)
 JQuery (MIT)
 JQuery Flot (MIT)

As per [3] there is not need to modify the NOTICE file when bundling permissive licenses.

Binary file in source release.
- Font files in resources/fonts. It is unclear how there are these licensed and where are
they from.

Some minor thing you may want to fix in future releases.
- Add a KEY file to the incubating release ares
- add "apache" to the release artefact name
- not sure that DEPENDANCIES is needed
- probably no need for LICENSE and LICENSE.txt
- Is year 2008-2013 correct in NOTICE file?
- No README (how to compile) or RELEASE_NOTES (changes form last version)
- and scripts are missing license header
- sb-admin.css  missing license header

The test failed with this error:
[ERROR] Failed to execute goal org.apache.maven.plugins:maven-shade-plugin:2.1:shade (default)
on project sirona-javaagent: Error creating shaded jar: /Users/justinmclean/Documents/Sirona0.2/apache-sirona-0.2-incubating/agent/performance/aop/target/classes
(Is a directory) -> [Help 1]


To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message