incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Endre StĂžlsvik <>
Subject Re: [DISCUSS] Community diversity (again)
Date Thu, 27 Mar 2008 09:55:17 GMT
Thilo Goetz wrote:

> It's just that to an outsider, it is totally unclear what that
> means.  And it may be impossible to really convey the meaning
> of it in a few sentences.  So why don't we just say so.
> Make it absolutely clear that the diversity of the community
> will be judged by the IPMC based on the overall conduct of the
> project, mailing list, commit activity etc.  I know it's there
> already, but it could be reinforced.  Perhaps at the end of the
> "Creating an Open and Diverse community" (community should be
> capitalized, btw) paragraph: "The IPMC will judge diversity of
> the project based on many criteria.  These include mailing list
> activity, commit activity and the affiliations of the committers.
> There is no single sufficient criterion, it is the overall conduct
> of the development community that counts."  Or something like that.

One obvious problem with such approaches is that the criteria will 
become very unevenly/unfairly applied. Some projects might just "slip 
past" with very little scrutiny, while others suddenly rack up a lot of 
discussion, where everybody has something to say and the project gets 
lots of (somewhat unwanted!) scrutiny. The amount of scrutiny and 
subjective evaluation will be affected by time of year, holidays and 
daily moods of the PMC members etc etc..!

An idea would be to have a pretty clear set of rules, with X committers, 
where all must actively have participated in email and subversion 
activity, blah blah - SOMETHING that can be objectively evaluated and 
the project may strive towards - and then some final line about "this 
will however be up to a final subjective evaluation where obvious 
attempts at circumventing/bypassing/"minimal-efforting" the system will 
(hopefully) be caught and stopped."


To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message