incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Garrett Rooney" <>
Subject Re: [VOTE] Accept Glasgow into Incubator
Date Thu, 03 Aug 2006 21:54:14 GMT
I'm sorry, but I have to vote -1 (binding).

I'm not in favor of the ASF endorsing a specification that seems to be
completely under the control of a small number of companies with no
way for new developers to participate in its development.  The fact
that we have done this in the past is unfortunate, but it doesn't
change things in my opinion.  AMQP seems to be moving in this
direction, they've got some sort of agreement you can sign in order to
provide them feedback, that's a step, but I don't see any mailing
lists, I don't see any way for someone who doesn't work for one of the
companies in question to join as an equal member, and in general I
think it's premature for the ASF to get involved, and accepting an
incubator project is getting involved.

Additionally, since we've already decided that we need to do
"something" about the open/closed specification question with regard
to incubator projects, I think it's unfair to bring a new project into
the incubator when it's possible that our decision could result in
that project not being able to graduate.  If we know we're going to
have that debate eventually we should do so now, to wait until after
the project is in incubation seems unfair to them.

Finally, and I hate to say this because it may very well be just a
cultural difference between projects the Glasgow developers have
worked on and the way things work in ASF projects I'm familiar with, I
think it's disturbing that all answers to questions concerning this
proposal have been discussed in private and fed back to us through a
single person.  I don't see a community of individuals here, I see a
collection of companies working to bring a new project to the ASF
because they can benefit from the brand, and while that can certainly
change with time its combination with the other problems means I can't
vote in favor of the proposal.


To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message