sis-commits mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Martin Desruisseaux (JIRA)" <j...@apache.org>
Subject [jira] [Updated] (SIS-378) Too aggressive simplification of some units of measurement
Date Sun, 05 Aug 2018 21:23:00 GMT

     [ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SIS-378?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]

Martin Desruisseaux updated SIS-378:
------------------------------------
    Description: 
In the left column, some units used by the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO). In the
right column, the result of parsing with Apache SIS. Some simplifications are too aggressive,
in particular with dimensionless units like radians.

|| WMO units       || SIS 0.8 parsing || SIS 0.8 || SIS 1.0 ||
|   K m2 kg-1 s-1  |       K⋅m²∕(kg⋅s)  |  (/) | (/) |
|        m m6 m-3  |                m⁴  |  (!) | (/) |
|          Pa s-1  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (/) |
|           S m-1  |     A²⋅s³∕(kg⋅m³)  |  (!) | (/) |
|   kg kg-1 m s-1  |               m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|        m2/3 s-1  |  0.3333333333333333⋅m²∕s  |  (x) | (/) |
|          J kg-1  |             m²∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|       mol mol-1  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
|         mol s-1  |             mol∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|           K s-1  |               K∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|           m s-1  |               m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|           m s-2  |              m∕s²  |  (/) | (/) |
|            Pa m  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|          m3 s-1  |              m³∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|      kg m-2 s-1  |         kg∕(m²⋅s)  |  (/) | (/) |
|          μg m-3  |      1.0E-9⋅kg∕m³  |  (!) | (/) |
|           K m-1  |               K∕m  |  (/) | (/) |
|           W m-2  |             kg∕s³  |  (!) | (/) |
|           N m-2  |                Pa  |  (?) | (?) |
|     (m2 s sr)-1  |           -1⋅m²⋅s  |  (x) | (x) |
|          kg m-2  |             kg∕m²  |  (/) | (/) |
|          kg m-3  |             kg∕m³  |  (/) | (/) |
|         K*m s-1  |             K⋅m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|          cm/day  |  1.1574074074074074E-7⋅m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|     m-2 s rad-1  |              s∕m²  |  (x) | (x) |
|         N m-2 s  |          kg∕(m⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
|     kg kg-1 s-1  |                Hz  |  (x) | (x) |
|     kg/kg*kg/kg  |                    |  (!) | (!) |
|           K*m/s  |             K⋅m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|      kg/kg*Pa/s  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |
|       kg/kg*m/s  |               m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|             day  |                 d  |  (/) | (/) |
|          µg m-3  |      1.0E-9⋅kg∕m³  |  (!) | (/) |
|           Pa*Pa  |       kg²∕(m²⋅s⁴)  |  (!) | (/) |
|      W m-2 Hz-1  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (!) |
|      W sr-1 m-2  |             kg∕s³  |  (x) | (x) |
|           N m-1  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|      W m-1 sr-1  |           kg⋅m∕s³  |  (x) | (x) |
|         m-2 s-1  |           ∕(m²⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
|               °  |                 °  |  (/) | (/) |
|         kg kg-1  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
|           s m-1  |               s∕m  |  (/) | (/) |
|      W m-3 sr-1  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (x) | (x) |
|          K*Pa/s  |       K⋅kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (/) |
|          m3 m-3  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
|           V m-1  |       kg⋅m∕(s³⋅A)  |  (!) | (/) |
|          m2 s-2  |             m²∕s²  |  (/) | (/) |
|          m2 s-1  |              m²∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|         mol m-3  |            mol∕m³  |  (/) | (/) |
|             psu  |               psu  |  (/) | (/) |
|           J m-2  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|        kg-2 s-1  |          ∕(kg²⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
|             K*K  |                K²  |  (/) |(/) |
|      kg m-3 s-1  |         kg∕(m³⋅s)  |  (/) |(/) |
|      m3 s-1 m-1  |              m²∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|(kg m-3) (m s-1)  |         kg∕(m²⋅s)  |  (!) | (!) |
|      W m-2 nm-1  |  9.999999999999999E8⋅kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |


  was:
In the left column, some units used by the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO). In the
right column, the result of parsing with Apache SIS. Some simplifications are too aggressive,
in particular with dimensionless units like radians.

|| WMO units       || SIS 0.8 parsing || SIS 0.8 || SIS 1.0 ||
|   K m2 kg-1 s-1  |       K⋅m²∕(kg⋅s)  |  (/) | (/) |
|        m m6 m-3  |                m⁴  |  (!) | (!) |
|          Pa s-1  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (/) |
|           S m-1  |     A²⋅s³∕(kg⋅m³)  |  (!) | (/) |
|   kg kg-1 m s-1  |               m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|        m2/3 s-1  |  0.3333333333333333⋅m²∕s  |  (x) | (/) |
|          J kg-1  |             m²∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|       mol mol-1  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
|         mol s-1  |             mol∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|           K s-1  |               K∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|           m s-1  |               m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|           m s-2  |              m∕s²  |  (/) | (/) |
|            Pa m  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|          m3 s-1  |              m³∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|      kg m-2 s-1  |         kg∕(m²⋅s)  |  (/) | (/) |
|          μg m-3  |      1.0E-9⋅kg∕m³  |  (!) | (/) |
|           K m-1  |               K∕m  |  (/) | (/) |
|           W m-2  |             kg∕s³  |  (!) | (/) |
|           N m-2  |                Pa  |  (?) | (?) |
|     (m2 s sr)-1  |           -1⋅m²⋅s  |  (x) | (x) |
|          kg m-2  |             kg∕m²  |  (/) | (/) |
|          kg m-3  |             kg∕m³  |  (/) | (/) |
|         K*m s-1  |             K⋅m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|          cm/day  |  1.1574074074074074E-7⋅m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|     m-2 s rad-1  |              s∕m²  |  (x) | (x) |
|         N m-2 s  |          kg∕(m⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
|     kg kg-1 s-1  |                Hz  |  (x) | (x) |
|     kg/kg*kg/kg  |                    |  (!) | (!) |
|           K*m/s  |             K⋅m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|      kg/kg*Pa/s  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |
|       kg/kg*m/s  |               m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|             day  |                 d  |  (/) | (/) |
|          µg m-3  |      1.0E-9⋅kg∕m³  |  (!) | (/) |
|           Pa*Pa  |       kg²∕(m²⋅s⁴)  |  (!) | (/) |
|      W m-2 Hz-1  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (!) |
|      W sr-1 m-2  |             kg∕s³  |  (x) | (x) |
|           N m-1  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|      W m-1 sr-1  |           kg⋅m∕s³  |  (x) | (x) |
|         m-2 s-1  |           ∕(m²⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
|               °  |                 °  |  (/) | (/) |
|         kg kg-1  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
|           s m-1  |               s∕m  |  (/) | (/) |
|      W m-3 sr-1  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (x) | (x) |
|          K*Pa/s  |       K⋅kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |
|          m3 m-3  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
|           V m-1  |       kg⋅m∕(s³⋅A)  |  (!) | (/) |
|          m2 s-2  |             m²∕s²  |  (/) | (/) |
|          m2 s-1  |              m²∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
|         mol m-3  |            mol∕m³  |  (/) | (/) |
|             psu  |               psu  |  (/) | (/) |
|           J m-2  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
|        kg-2 s-1  |          ∕(kg²⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
|             K*K  |                K²  |  (/) |(/) |
|      kg m-3 s-1  |         kg∕(m³⋅s)  |  (/) |(/) |
|      m3 s-1 m-1  |              m²∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
|(kg m-3) (m s-1)  |         kg∕(m²⋅s)  |  (!) | (!) |
|      W m-2 nm-1  |  9.999999999999999E8⋅kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |



> Too aggressive simplification of some units of measurement
> ----------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: SIS-378
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SIS-378
>             Project: Spatial Information Systems
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: Utilities
>    Affects Versions: 0.8
>            Reporter: Martin Desruisseaux
>            Assignee: Martin Desruisseaux
>            Priority: Major
>             Fix For: 1.0
>
>
> In the left column, some units used by the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO). In
the right column, the result of parsing with Apache SIS. Some simplifications are too aggressive,
in particular with dimensionless units like radians.
> || WMO units       || SIS 0.8 parsing || SIS 0.8 || SIS 1.0 ||
> |   K m2 kg-1 s-1  |       K⋅m²∕(kg⋅s)  |  (/) | (/) |
> |        m m6 m-3  |                m⁴  |  (!) | (/) |
> |          Pa s-1  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (/) |
> |           S m-1  |     A²⋅s³∕(kg⋅m³)  |  (!) | (/) |
> |   kg kg-1 m s-1  |               m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
> |        m2/3 s-1  |  0.3333333333333333⋅m²∕s  |  (x) | (/) |
> |          J kg-1  |             m²∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
> |       mol mol-1  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
> |         mol s-1  |             mol∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |           K s-1  |               K∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |           m s-1  |               m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |           m s-2  |              m∕s²  |  (/) | (/) |
> |            Pa m  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
> |          m3 s-1  |              m³∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |      kg m-2 s-1  |         kg∕(m²⋅s)  |  (/) | (/) |
> |          μg m-3  |      1.0E-9⋅kg∕m³  |  (!) | (/) |
> |           K m-1  |               K∕m  |  (/) | (/) |
> |           W m-2  |             kg∕s³  |  (!) | (/) |
> |           N m-2  |                Pa  |  (?) | (?) |
> |     (m2 s sr)-1  |           -1⋅m²⋅s  |  (x) | (x) |
> |          kg m-2  |             kg∕m²  |  (/) | (/) |
> |          kg m-3  |             kg∕m³  |  (/) | (/) |
> |         K*m s-1  |             K⋅m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |          cm/day  |  1.1574074074074074E-7⋅m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
> |     m-2 s rad-1  |              s∕m²  |  (x) | (x) |
> |         N m-2 s  |          kg∕(m⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
> |     kg kg-1 s-1  |                Hz  |  (x) | (x) |
> |     kg/kg*kg/kg  |                    |  (!) | (!) |
> |           K*m/s  |             K⋅m∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |      kg/kg*Pa/s  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |
> |       kg/kg*m/s  |               m∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
> |             day  |                 d  |  (/) | (/) |
> |          µg m-3  |      1.0E-9⋅kg∕m³  |  (!) | (/) |
> |           Pa*Pa  |       kg²∕(m²⋅s⁴)  |  (!) | (/) |
> |      W m-2 Hz-1  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (!) |
> |      W sr-1 m-2  |             kg∕s³  |  (x) | (x) |
> |           N m-1  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
> |      W m-1 sr-1  |           kg⋅m∕s³  |  (x) | (x) |
> |         m-2 s-1  |           ∕(m²⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
> |               °  |                 °  |  (/) | (/) |
> |         kg kg-1  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
> |           s m-1  |               s∕m  |  (/) | (/) |
> |      W m-3 sr-1  |         kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (x) | (x) |
> |          K*Pa/s  |       K⋅kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (/) |
> |          m3 m-3  |                    |  (!) | (/) |
> |           V m-1  |       kg⋅m∕(s³⋅A)  |  (!) | (/) |
> |          m2 s-2  |             m²∕s²  |  (/) | (/) |
> |          m2 s-1  |              m²∕s  |  (/) | (/) |
> |         mol m-3  |            mol∕m³  |  (/) | (/) |
> |             psu  |               psu  |  (/) | (/) |
> |           J m-2  |             kg∕s²  |  (!) | (/) |
> |        kg-2 s-1  |          ∕(kg²⋅s)  |  (!) | (?) |
> |             K*K  |                K²  |  (/) |(/) |
> |      kg m-3 s-1  |         kg∕(m³⋅s)  |  (/) |(/) |
> |      m3 s-1 m-1  |              m²∕s  |  (!) | (!) |
> |(kg m-3) (m s-1)  |         kg∕(m²⋅s)  |  (!) | (!) |
> |      W m-2 nm-1  |  9.999999999999999E8⋅kg∕(m⋅s³)  |  (!) | (!) |



--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v7.6.3#76005)

Mime
View raw message