logging-log4cxx-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Curt Arnold <carn...@apache.org>
Subject Re: Logging macro stream support
Date Tue, 21 Jun 2005 22:44:31 GMT
On Jun 21, 2005, at 3:39 PM, Moul, Russell G wrote:
> I noticed that the LOG4CXX_DEBUG and related macros no longer support
> stream concatination.  Are there inherent problems with the stream
> concatination in the macros or were they removed for other reasons?
> Thanks
> Russ

The log4cxx 0.9.7 macros had as an undocumented (without looking at  
the macro source) semantic of accepting any right hand side of an  
std::ostream operator<<.  That is you could do:

LOG4CXX_DEBUG(logger, "Iteration " << i);

which would expand to something like:

if (logger->isDebugEnabled()) }
    std::ostringstream os;
    os << "Iteration " << i;

There are a couple of issues with this behavior.  First, it was very  
difficult to generalize to support multiple character types, so if  
you did:

LOG4CXX_DEBUG(logger, L"Iteration" << i);

You would get a message about an undeclared operator<<(const  
wchar_t*).  In addition, it added an unnecessary std::ostringstream  
construction and destruction in the common case that the message was  
simply a text literal or string.

It seemed better to split the stream insertion operators into a  
separate API (the logstream) and simply the LOG4CXX_ macros to have  
the equivalent semantics of

#define LOG4CXX_DEBUG(logger, msg) \

But with hidden optimizations.

The logstream work stalled before really coming to a satisfactory  
conclusion and there has been interest in restarting it.

log4j 1.3 has now added additional parameterized logging methods like:

logger.debug("Iteration {}",new Integer(i));


logger.debug("Iteration {} of {}", new Integer(i), new Integer(limit));

It would be nice to bring these over to log4cxx, but no work has been  
done on that yet.  I do not believe that you can support variable  
number of parameters in a macro, so you'd need to pick a fixed number  
of arguments and do something like:

#define LOG4CXX_PARAM_DEBUG(logger, msg, param1, param2) \
log4cxx::parameterizedDebug(logger, msg, param1, param2,  

with some template definition that could handle the various  

View raw message