incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Chris Thistlethwaite <>
Subject [VOTE] Accept Warble into the Apache Incubator
Date Fri, 08 Jun 2018 14:43:53 GMT
Hi All (again),

I'd like to start a vote on accepting Warble into the Apache Incubator.

The ASF voting rules are described:

A vote for accepting a new Apache Incubator podling is a majority vote
for which only Incubator PMC member votes are binding.

This vote will run for at least 72 hours. Please VOTE as follows
[ ] +1 Accept Warble into the Apache Incubator
[ ] +0 Abstain.
[ ] -1 Do not accept Warble into the Incubator

The proposal is listed below, but you can also access it on the wiki:

Thank you,
Chris T.

= Apache Warble Proposal =

== Abstract ==

    Apache Warble is a distributed endpoint monitoring solution where
    the agent is hosted on your own hardware. The aim of Warble is to
    produce a more balanced and less binary view of services and
    systems, lowering the rates of false positives while also providing
    greater insight into possible peering issues and proactive trend
==    Proposal ==
    The goal of Warble will be to bring internal control of
    distributed monitoring back to the end user. Warble can be used as
    an independent service running on your own infrastructure
    monitoring other services in your infrastructure. 
==     Background and Rationale ==
    The beginning of this project was prompted by the service (PMB) going end of life. This brought up
    conversation about FOSS services that can monitor internal and
    external services. PMB offered a unique code base to build this
    service upon a known infrastructure.
===    Initial Goals ===

    Bring PMB code into the ASF, refactor the client/server into 
    a more reusable structure. Further reuse of code gives us the a
    great starting point to build a starting point. 
==    Current Status ==
    The software exists as a proprietary service. We wish to convert
    this to a FLOSS solution.
==    Meritocracy ==
    The initial PMC list covers new folks coming into the ASF. 
==    Community ==
    There exists a large user-base of software like Warble, as well 
    as existing users of the old propietary service. It is our hope
    that we can convert a great deal of these to contributors and
    testers for the new open source product.
==    Core Developers ==
    The initial set of developers are a lot of newcomers:

    * Daniel Gruno <>
    * Chris Thistlethwaite <>
    * Haig Didizian <>
    * Andrew Karetas <>
    * Chandler Claxton <>
    * Luke Stevens <>
    * Mike Andescavage <>
    * Chris Lambertus <>
==    Known Risks ==
    There are many existing services that provide external 
    monitoring. They are well established and have large user bases.
===    Orphaned Products ===
    The initial PMC has great interest in open source projects, though
    no formal projects have been run.
===    Inexperience with Open Source ===
    Most of the initial PPMC members are new to the ASF and some are
    new to open source projects. However, all are very interested in
    giving back to the community and projects.  Having said that, there
    are several people involved with extensive experience in the
    Apache Way and our procedures and processes.
===    Homogenous Developers ===
    The initial set of developers are employed by a variety of
    companies, located across the world, and used to working on a
    variety of distributed projects.
===    Reliance on Salaried Developers ===
    We do not expect the interest of the proposed initial PMC to be
    directly tied to current employment, but will actively seek to
    grow our volunteer base regardless.
===    Relationships with Other Apache Products ===
    Not much to say here. Many ASF projects make use of the proprietary
    offering, we wish to open source it and have people engage in the
    development of the project. There are, at present, indirect
    relationships in that some dependencies are built on Apache
    software, but these are generally by proxy and does not merit
    considering Warble as a sub-project of an existing TLP.
==    Initial Source ==
    The initial task of the PMC will be assessing what we wish the
    project to contain. The proprietary vendor is willing to donate the
    software, but considerable rewriting and relicensing will have to
    take place. This will likely happen in stages, with the scrapers
    and UI being ported first, and a backend auth system being partly
    ported/donated, and partly developed from scratch at the ASF.
===    Source and Intellectual Property Submission Plan ===
    All the existing code in question (from the PMB suite) is owned by
    Quenda IvS, and will be donated to the ASF.
===    External Dependencies ===
    The current code base depends on incompatible licenses for
    visualizations. We will work towards 100% compatibility with the
    Apache License v/2.
===    Cryptography ===
    Warble will make use of some SSL/TLS and cryptography in order to
    transmit data between nodes and main server, however we will not
    be incorporating any cryptography in the project code itself, but
    rather rely on existing encryption libraries and protocols.
==    Required Resources ==
===    Mailing Lists ===
     (moderated subscriptions)
===    Repositories ===
===    Issue Tracking ===
    We will be starting with just GitHub Issues/PRs and later assess
    the possible need for something else.
===    Other Resources ===
    We have no other requirements at present.
    We will require one or more VMs at some point, however, it may be
    the case that we can get these donated by companies interested in
    furthering the development of the project.

===    domain name: ===
==    Initial PMC ==

    * Daniel Gruno <>
    * Chris Thistlethwaite <>
    * Haig Didizian <>
    * Andrew Karetas <>
    * Chandler Claxton <>
    * Luke Stevens <>
    * Mike Andescavage <>
===    Affiliations ===
    PMC members are employees of ASF, Microsoft, Evolve Guest
    Solutions, Revolt Consulting, and independently employed
==    Sponsors ==
===    Champion ===
    Daniel Gruno <>
===     Nominated Mentors ===
    Daniel Pono Takamori <>
===    Sponsoring Entity ===

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message