incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Stian Soiland-Reyes <>
Subject Re: TSU/ECCN notification for Impala podling
Date Thu, 17 Nov 2016 16:45:36 GMT
As you have noted in,
"Designed for use with OpenSSL" sounds right to me for Impala - which
makes Impala an "Encryption item".

See also

Correct that our policy is that Ted Dunning will have to send it as
the PMC chair - you need to update your "SUBMITTED BY" line (and
probably in the XML).

Personally I would also not send an encryption notice to a foreign
government authority without being somewhat legally protected as an
ASF officer. :-)

On 15 November 2016 at 04:11, John D. Ament <> wrote:
> Todd,
> Please be cautious about mixing public/private email lists.  I'm removing
> impala's private based on this.
> The guide that Sailesh pointed to [1] mentions the "PMC Chair" which would
> be the Incubator PMC, and hence Ted Dunning.  If you don't hear back, may
> be best to ping him directly (I had assumed this was what Sailesh did).
> I just want to confirm, when you're talking about using OpenSSL, its more
> than just "you need to run Impala on a (Tomcat|HTTPd) instance with SSL
> enabled (e.g. the user would do that) and you're actually linking to
> OpenSSL in your product?
> John
> [1]:
> On Mon, Nov 14, 2016 at 6:49 PM Todd Lipcon <> wrote:
>> Hey folks,
>> I'm helping out the Impala podling with their ECCN (crypto export) notice.
>> I added them to the page at (well,
>> really I just committed a patch provided by Sailesh Mukil). The next step
>> is to send the TSU NOTIFICATION email to the various US Government email
>> addresses.
>> I see Sailesh emailed general@ 11 days ago asking about who can send this
>> notice but didn't hear back. So now I'm trying again on his behalf :) As an
>> IPMC member and ASF member can I send in the notification, or would we
>> prefer that someone else do it? The generated email attached below lists
>> Roman as the contact, but iirc Ted Dunning is the current IPMC chair.
>> To:,,
>> Cc:, {applicable project list}
>> Subject: TSU NOTIFICATION - Encryption
>> ---EMAIL BODY---
>> SUBMITTED BY:         Roman Shaposhnik
>> SUBMITTED FOR:        The Apache Software Foundation
>> POINT OF CONTACT:     Secretary, The Apache Software Foundation
>> FAX:                  +1-919-573-9199 <(919)%20573-9199>
>> MANUFACTURER(S):      The Apache Software Foundation
>> PRODUCT NAME/MODEL #: Apache Impala
>> ECCN:                 5D002

Stian Soiland-Reyes

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message