incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Kevan Miller <>
Subject Re: svn commit: r1488735 - in /incubator/public/trunk/tools: NOTICE.txt requirements.txt src/asf/utils/ src/asf/utils/ src/asf/utils/ src/asf/utils/ tests/
Date Tue, 04 Jun 2013 12:58:46 GMT

On Jun 4, 2013, at 8:46 AM, Greg Stein <> wrote:

> On Jun 4, 2013 4:22 AM, "ant elder" <> wrote:
>> On Tue, Jun 4, 2013 at 1:45 AM, Greg Stein <> wrote:
>>> Simple as that.
>> If only.
>> This is the old "what goes in the NOTICE file" debate that has
>> probably caused more emails and confusion than any other topic here.
>> My understanding of the current thinking on this is to only include
>> something in the NOTICE file when there is a clear legal requirement,
>> and that probably means some explicit documentation at ASF Legal for
>> the specific case (i.e raise a Legal JIRA asking). If any attribution
>> is required or wanted then its probably done by including the license
>> / copyright in the LICENSE file or the attribution should be added to
>> the README or to a separate CREDITS type file. There are numerous
>> discussions on this list about that and JIRA's like LEGAL-62 (wasn't
>> there a post from Roy once saying he'd have artifacts removed from the
>> distribution area if people had added random stuff to the NOTICE?).
>> This "when in doubt leave it out" approach has gone a long way at
>> smoothing podling release reviews compared to the olden days.
> Seriously? The inserted code uses our own license! Go look at 4(d) and tell
> me we should not insert a notice. It is both Right, and what is demanded by
> our own license.

I haven't seen a description of where this code is coming from. Is it a contribution from
LinkedIn? Is it some open source code from LinkedIn that we are copying into our svn from
some other project?

If it's the former and LinkedIn has requested attribution for their contribution, then let's
observe their request and add attribution to the NOTICE.

If it's the latter *and* the subject code has a NOTICE file, then we absolutely must include
the relevant portions of their NOTICE in our NOTICE. Otherwise, 4 (d) doesn't require us to
do anything. Agreed?

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message