incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Shane Curcuru <>
Subject Re: [DISCUSS] Accept Stratos as an Apache Incubation Project
Date Fri, 14 Jun 2013 14:56:52 GMT
One comment that I wish I could express more clearly:

On 6/14/2013 10:42 AM, Mattmann, Chris A (398J) wrote:
> * pTLP are nothing different than what existed before there was an
> Incubator. Yes we have more projects now. So what. We'll continue
> to have more projects and those will eventually graduate to TLP,
> so we'll be in the same place.

Actually, from the *outside* perspective, it's completely different. 
The Incubator has podlings, this weird thing that most people don't 
quite understand, but know that it's weird, so they look at the 
Incubator site enough to understand "Oh, it's kind of at Apache, but 
it's not an *Apache project*".

pTLPs are something that... well, the "p" is lowercase, so who cares - 
they're just TLPs which is pretty easy to google to top level project, 
which means - a-ha! - here's a brand new *Apache project*!  And look - 
they're totally run by SoAndSo Co - what, is Apache now pay to play, 
allowing an Apache project to work like that?

This distinction - as seen in the view of the general computer using 
public, and especially in the view of those in positions of authority at 
corporations that use/build/create software - is *very* important to 
helping to define the Apache brand.

It's taken a while to educate enough of the press and other open source 
watchers to understand what podlings are, and the whole concept not only 
of probation, but also the concept of incubation: i.e. not just waiting 
until the new podling does the right kinds of things, but actively 
helping and guiding the community to learning and embracing The Apache 
Way of doing things... at which point, they graduate and then become an 
Apache project.

As VP, Brand, I believe this is an important issue.  But I often don't 
know how to explain it, precisely because we all here know what podlings 
and pTLPs and so on are - what is important to me is the perception of 
the *rest* of the world who *doesn't* know what they are.  Nor does the 
rest of the world care about the details - what they care about is: is 
it an Apache project?  If so, it's got good community, a safe license, 
will be around for a while, and I know I can contribute to it safely 
without being abused by competitors/bigcos/whoever.  That's what the 
Apache brand means.

- Shane

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message