incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Roland Weber <>
Subject Re: draft proposal for Caitrin
Date Wed, 07 May 2008 17:18:54 GMT
Martijn Dashorst wrote:
> On 5/6/08, Roland Weber <> wrote:
>>  I think the Roller option makes more sense. I doubt that
>>  a podling without three committers would even be accepted.
> Not true, it is even one of the options on the table when starting a
> new project. Start without any committer, and grow the community
> through meritocracy. Everybody starts anew in this scenario.

Fair enough. The Proposal Guide says "Apache is interested
only in communities." but that is not policy.

> This
> scenario just doesn't work well for established open source projects
> joining the ASF as they typically already have folks with a lot of
> merit in their team.
> However, starting without committers is a really hard thing. You have
> to publicize the heck out of it.

And spend a lot of time learning about "The Apache Way".
Getting the podling up to speed is no small task for a
single person, even if mentors help with it.

>>  Since there are interested people at Roller, you have a chance
>>  to grow the community there.
> I think that one of the goals of the incubator is to grow podlings to
> the point that they can manage themselves.

I'm concerned about the starting point from which to grow.
Apache committers have the Labs to get started and attract
a few interested people before coming to the Incubator.
A non-committer coming to the Incubator directly faces a
really steep learning curve.


> If the goal of this podling
> is to become a subproject of roller, then it can join the incubator,
> sponsored by the Roller PMC (if the Roller PMC is willing).
> Basically I see three options for becoming part of the ASF for this proposal:
>  1. become part of the Roller community directly (through the usual
> meritocratic process, i.e. help out in the Roller community, provide
> patches, etc) and attract more developers there
>  2. become a sub project of Roller, but grow the community here
>  3. become a top level project, and grow the community here
> For 1 you'll need to contact the Roller community and make them
> enthousiastic about your project so they'll accept the code (and
> yourself).
> For 2 and 3 you'll need to find a Sponsor and a Champion (the Sponsor
> is the Roller PMC in #2, and the Incubator PMC in #3), the Champion
> can be any Member of the ASF.
> Martijn
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail:
> For additional commands, e-mail:

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message