incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Ted Leung <>
Subject [VOTE] Revised Heraldry commit ACL
Date Wed, 21 Mar 2007 05:19:59 GMT
Hi folks,

The Incubator PMC has asked the Heraldry mentors for a new commit ACL  
for the project, and the deadline set by the Incubator PMC (March  
19th) has now passed.    Those interested in the full discussion on  
Noel's request can follow the thread starting here: <http://mail->

Based on that discussion, the only names that I can see submitting  
for a revised commit ACL are:

David Recordon (recordond)
Johannes Ernst (jernst)
Matt Pelletier (mattpelletier)

Other committers to Ruby PIP are:

Dan Quellhorst
Hans Granqvist
Gary Krall
Trotter Cashion
Mike Graves

Noel's original message said that the Incubator PMC would either  
replace the old commit ACL or remove it entirely.  So I'm bringing  
this back to the Incubator PMC for discussion and ultimately, a vote.

I would also point out that I am currently the only mentor for  
Heraldry, and I'm not willing to continue without some other people  
jumping in to help.  When I originally agreed to mentor Heraldry, I  
did it thinking that I was one of three mentors.


On Mar 13, 2007, at 10:28 PM, Ted Leung wrote:

> Ok,
> Here's how I'd like to handle this.  If you want to continue to be  
> a committer on Heraldry - which means that you actually worked on  
> the Ruby PIP (since that's the only code we have left), then please  
> reply and indicate that, and your affiliation.    You must do this  
> yourself.  I will not be accepting a block submission of names for  
> the new committer list.   If you can't be bothered to send this e- 
> mail yourself, then you won't like the amount of work that it is  
> going to take to get Heraldry going.
> Thanks,
> Ted
> On Mar 13, 2007, at 11:53 AM, Noel J. Bergman wrote:
>> The Incubator PMC has been discussing Heraldry.  We need to make  
>> it clear
>> that there is only one set of rules that will be tolerated here,  
>> and those
>> are ours.  Anyone who is willing to abide by them is enthusiasticaly
>> welcomed to participate.  But anyone who isn't willing to abide by  
>> our basic
>> rules for open, collaborative, development cannot be permitted to  
>> trade on
>> the ASF's good name.
>> The Mentors are asked to submit a new Committer list and suggested  
>> consisting of anyone who is prepared to operating under our rules,  
>> and
>> expresses that interest.  If such a list cannot be produced, we're  
>> prepared
>> to close the project.  But we do hope that there are sufficient  
>> people
>> interested and willing to work on this project in an open and  
>> collaborative
>> manner.
>> We would like this list by March 19, at which point we will either  
>> replace
>> the commit ACL or remove it.
>> The revised group will be charged with reviewing the Heraldry  
>> charter -- the
>> remaining scope of the project will need to be reevaluated in  
>> light of the
>> changes -- and resubmitting that plan to the Incubator PMC for  
>> review.
>> 	--- Noel

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message