incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Mark Little <>
Subject Problem with commit rights on Celtixfire
Date Fri, 29 Sep 2006 09:06:30 GMT
Redhat were one of the supporters of the Celtixfire incubator project  
and discussed with the proposers to add Kevin Conner and myself to  
the list of initial commiters. As part of this, our names were  
included in the proposal. Both Kevin and I are working on Redhat  
related projects and see a lot of potential collaboration  
possibilities with Celtixfire.

At the formation of the project all members of the group were asked  
to submit signed ICLAs, which we did via fax and snail-mail. However,  
due to a problem with the fax, after 4 weeks they hadn't turned up  
and we re-submitted. This time, at the start of September, the ICLAs  
were acknowledged and we were told our commiter status was in the  
works. However, despite several follow up emails, commiter status was  
not given and no answer for the delay provided.

Yesterday we learnt that there has been some internal decision to  
limit the number of commiters and not take into account the listed  
individuals on the initial commiters list. Is this normal procedure?  
Have we been waiting 2 months based on false assumptions? We believed  
that, as supporters of the submission, we had already gone through  
the process of arguing who should, or should not, be an initial  
commiter, so to be presented with a different result (and one which  
appears to have been conducted behind closed doors) is frustrating.

Clearly this is not a case of "piling on", as joining the project was  
discussed with the project submitters prior to the formation of the  
group. Something seems wrong here; if there was no intention of  
adding us (and perhaps others we don't know about) as initial  
commiters, why did the project submitter include us? On what basis  
where these accounts not set up? Is random denial of initial  
commiters typical?




Director of Standards, Development Manager, JBoss (a Division of  
  • Unnamed multipart/alternative (inline, None, 0 bytes)
View raw message